The Longbow Papers

Link to Main Blog Page
 

Tuesday, September 14, 2004

Is It Really Worse Than We Think...?

Paul Krugman nails a bush screw-ball and drives it out of the yard. I probably shouldn't use a baseball metaphor in a post about what is going on in Iraq. My defense is that baseball is serious business, art, and passionate pleasure to me. My mind goes to the diamond first whenever I am trying to understand something myself, or I am trying to explain something I do understand to others--in other words, it is almost always my first frame of reference for just about everything in life.

Mr. Krugman's column in today's The New York Times connects with the twisting, diving junk-ball stuff coming out of the bush administration so squarely that his words are like a line-drive that never gets much higher than the leftfield wall but there is never any doubt it's a dinger. I am going to post it in full because I want it as a permanent record in these pages. He titles it: Taking On the Myth
On Sunday, a celebrating crowd gathered around a burning U.S. armored vehicle. Then a helicopter opened fire; a child and a journalist for an Arabic TV news channel were among those killed. Later, the channel repeatedly showed the journalist doubling over and screaming, "I'm dying; I'm dying."

Such scenes, which enlarge the ranks of our enemies by making America look both weak and brutal, are inevitable in the guerrilla war President Bush got us into. Osama bin Laden must be smiling.

U.S. news organizations are under constant pressure to report good news from Iraq. In fact, as a Newsweek headline puts it, "It's worse than you think." Attacks on coalition forces are intensifying and getting more effective; no-go zones, which the military prefers to call "insurgent enclaves," are spreading -- even in Baghdad. We're losing ground.

And the losses aren't only in Iraq. Al Qaeda has regrouped. The invasion of Iraq, intended to demonstrate American power, has done just the opposite: nasty regimes around the world feel empowered now that our forces are bogged down. When a Times reporter asked Mr. Bush about North Korea's ongoing nuclear program, "he opened his palms and shrugged."

Yet many voters still believe that Mr. Bush is doing a good job protecting America.

If Senator John Kerry really has advisers telling him not to attack Mr. Bush on national security, he should dump them. When Dick Cheney is saying vote Bush or die, responding with speeches about jobs and health care doesn't cut it.

Mr. Kerry should counterattack by saying that Mr. Bush is endangering the nation by subordinating national security to politics.

In early 2002 the Bush administration, already focused on Iraq, ignored pleas to commit more forces to Afghanistan. As a result, the Taliban is resurgent, and Osama is still out there.

In the buildup to the Iraq war, commanders wanted a bigger invasion force to help secure the country. But civilian officials, eager to prove that wars can be fought on the cheap, refused. And that's one main reason our soldiers are still dying in Iraq.

This past April, U.S. forces, surely acting on White House orders after American television showed gruesome images of dead contractors, attacked Falluja. Lt. Gen. James Conway, the Marine commander on the scene, opposed "attacking out of revenge" but was overruled -- and he was overruled again with an equally disastrous decision to call off the attack after it had begun. "Once you commit," General Conway said, "you got to stay committed." But Mr. Bush, faced with the prospect of a casualty toll that would have hurt his approval rating, didn't.

Can Mr. Kerry, who voted to authorize the Iraq war, criticize it? Yes, by pointing out that he voted only to give Mr. Bush a big stick. Once that stick had forced Saddam to let W.M.D. inspectors back in, there was no need to invade. And Mr. Kerry should keep pounding Mr. Cheney, who is trying to cover for the absence of W.M.D. by lying, yet again, about Saddam's ties to Al Qaeda.

Some pundits are demanding that Mr. Kerry produce a specific plan for Iraq -- a demand they never make of Mr. Bush. Mr. Kerry should turn the tables, and demand to know what -- aside from pretending that things are going fine -- Mr. Bush intends to do about the spiraling disaster. And Mr. Kerry can ask why anyone should trust a leader who refuses to replace the people who created that disaster because he thinks it's bad politics to admit a mistake.

Mr. Kerry can argue that he wouldn't have overruled the commanders who had wanted to keep the pressure on Al Qaeda, or dismissed warnings from former Gen. Eric Shinseki, then the Army's chief of staff, that peacekeeping would require a large force. He wouldn't have ignored General Conway's warnings about the dangers of storming into Falluja, or overruled his protests about calling off that assault halfway through.

On the other hand, he can argue that he would have fired Paul Wolfowitz, the deputy defense secretary who ridiculed General Shinseki. And he would definitely have fired Donald Rumsfeld for the failure to go in with enough troops, the atrocities at Abu Ghraib and more.

The truth is that Mr. Bush, by politicizing the "war on terror," is putting America at risk. And Mr. Kerry has to say that.
The New York Times
 


2:39 PM / Editor / permalink    2 comments

Links to this post:

2 Comments:

Mind boggling

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:53 AM  

Yes, but was it the screw-ball or the dinger that boggled you?

Thank you for visiting this site and taking the time to leave a comment. Please come back when you can.

Joseph

By Blogger Joseph, at 11:11 AM  

Post a Comment




The LongBow Papers at Blogged Blog Directory - Blogged
Home Page
The Time of My Life
Read Joseph Bosco
Website for Students
Email Joseph Bosco
WOW: We Observe the World
Previous Posts

Young Republicans Display Brain-Wave Activity Sign...
Out of Control...
Forget The Vietnam Comparisons, Iraq Will Win Its ...
Heroes Come In Shades of Grey...
They Did This In Our Name
What's 1,000,000 Lost Votes Mean To A Man Whose So...
As the Screw Turns...
"Disgraceful" Is Too Kind of a Word...
I Like Florida, too, But There Are Hundreds of Chi...
Failure To Carry Out A Direct Order...that's not a...


Featured Articles
A Moment In Beijing
Twin Giants of Asia
Free Floating RMB
Mississippi Sorrows
Coming Full Cycle in
the Taiwan Strait





 

 
 
     


Site Meter